The palm represents: Purpose, Prompt, and Plan for pre-writing activities
Then your students have to decide what their WOW the reader hook will be that will go with their Position Statement in the introduction.
(NOTE: It is not required that the position statement appears in the introduction, but it is probably a good idea to make sure your weaker students include it sooner than later.)
The word transition is written underneath the palm to remind your students to include a meaningful phrase or sentence that moves the essay from the introduction to the body.
The thumb stands for: Why? What is the reason you chose that idea? This finger starts the body of the essay. I don't recommend telling your students to write their reasons as a preview statement in the introduction since this practice usually ends up causing repetition. (Preview statements are a formulaic way to structure the essay that takes away some of the thoughtfulness and creativity when it comes to transitioning to the body.)
The pointer finger is for your first point or example. What example can you give to support your reason? For secondary students, the following examples can be used to explain reasons: real life personal examples/anecdotes, hypothetical examples that can and do happen, current event examples/situations using the news media, internet, songs, videos, books, shows, movies, etc, or historical examples using people or events from the past.
The middle finger is where most students fall short in expository. They forget that the key to the body is explaining your examples or reasons. They can use what I call I.F. details (Information and Facts) such as Why, What, Who, When, Where, Which, & How to add details/sentences for each example. For STAAR this section is to help with the development portion of the rubric. Your kids are not supposed just make lists of reasons or examples in the body. They must spend a paragraph EXPLAINING each reason. There is no magic number of sentences needed for development, but the longer the student can explain each reason/example specifically, the better the grade will be!
The ring finger represents choosing the words carefully, which is where the high vocabulary and voice will come into play. Since this is for persuasive writing, this is the portion of the essay where your students might briefly address another V, various viewpoints that don't fall in line with the position being taken by the writer.
When your strongest students end up with threes from each grader instead of fours on STAAR, it is usually because the essay is missing the aspects of this finger, how to "engage" the reader and keep them that way. You may also want to teach your students to memorize the TOES acronym at the bottom of the sheet that will give your kids the opportunity to add unique, original, & thoughtful details as they write.
The word transition is written between the ring finger and the pinky to remind your students to include a transitional phrase or sentence to move in a meaningful way from the body to the conclusion.
The last finger is the pinky for the ending or conclusion. This section is what I call the leftovers section if all your students do is repeat or restate everything they have written in the body or introduction. There is nothing creative or unique in asking students to rewrite things they have already written. Try to get them to write dessert for their conclusions, that give an extension and/or reflection about the topic, idea, examples, and/or the way they were explained. As a reader of a persuasive essay, you want to see a call to action, that will encourage or evoke change and transformation if the world in general was to do something as a result of the essay being written