In my fifth grade class-by the end of the school year students are to read at least 25 books. After each book is read they complete a Reading Response in their Reading Response Notebook. To guide students, I attach the Reading Response Guideline and Rubric (see product) in their notebooks and this way they can reference back to it to see what sort of information I am looking for within their response.
The guideline specifies what is to be included for either a fiction or non-fiction book and the rubric outlines the grade they will get.
The Guideline and Rubric is a 2 page word document and so once downloaded if you needed to make any minor changes you could do so.