The attached PDF contains guided notes and practice problems regarding the 4 angle-side postulates.
The two guided notes problems cover ASA, and AAS. There is a short section of guided notes so students can feel comfortable determine which of the 4 postulates to use before diving into the four proofs on the second page.
The second page contains 4 proofs which can be cut up and made into a booklet. This incentivized my students to finish the proofs in a timely manner so that the booklet could be made. One proof is SSS, one is SAS, one is AAS, and one is ASA. I had students put which postulate they were going to use in the cloud next to each proof.
To differentiate, I gave some students the amount of steps involved in each proof, and some students were given a "word bank" for possible statements and reasons.
My students did well with this assignment. It can be made more interactive by partnering up, or having students make posters out of a proof they want to publish.