Another spin on characterization, in addition to the Target Notes. This product is a PDF made for Gene Forrester from Knowles' A Separate Peace. However, it can easily be recreated and reused for any character undergoing an internal conflict.
I usually use this once we get about halfway, maybe around chapter 8, and have the kids list AS MANY ideas as they can think of. Sometimes they start independently, then collaborate with students around them. Usually, I like to make a huge list of combined ideas on our board.