Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)

Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Compare and Contrast Similar Stories (RL.2.9 and RL.3.9)
Common Core State Standards
Product Rating
File Type

Compressed Zip File

Be sure that you have an application to open this file type before downloading and/or purchasing.

26 MB|80 pages
Product Description

Compare and Contrast similar stories: Differentiated unit for 2nd or 3rd grade!

This unit is full of what you need to teach about comparing and contrasting similar fairy tales (RL.2.9) and comparing contrasting similar stories by the same author (RL.3.9). The materials are all differentiated for your learners who need a little extra support and for those who are ready for more complex tasks.


This unit is aligned to the Common Core standards of RL.2.9 and RL.3.9. However, everything is referred to by title, instead of number. Non-Common Core schools will not be distracted by Common Core language or terminology.


Every classroom has a range of learners. Some students need to move at a slower pace. Others are ready for more advanced work. This pack includes activities for ALL of these learners. Everything is differentiated. Activities are discreetly marked so that you know, but your students do not.


2nd-3rd Grade Reading Notebook (Literature)

2nd-3rd Grade Reading Notebook (Literature + Informational Text BUNDLE)


2nd-3rd Grade Reading Notebook (Informational Texts)


4th-5th Reading Notebook (Informational Text)

***********WHAT IS INCLUDED IN THIS UNIT? ***********

Mentor Text List

This list of suggested books works great for student texts or using in an Interactive Read Aloud.

Notebook Supplies

The notebook cover, tabs, chapter covers, and pockets are all included. Everything here fits perfectly into a notebook. It is all minimal prep and minimal cutting and pasting. However, there is also the option of print and go pages . You do not have to use a notebook with these materials.

Reading Bookmark

The bookmark is a reminder to the student of how to apply the skills they are learning. It includes sentence prompts and questions they should think about while reading. The prompt works seamlessly with everything in this pack.

Differentiated Passages and Questions

There are twelve original stories included. Each story is written at two differentiated levels for a total of twenty-four stories. There are two question page options included. One is closely aligned to the 2nd grade standards. The other is more closely aligned to the 3rd grade standards. With both options, students must color text evidence to support their responses. You have a range of differentiation options.

Differentiated Task Cards

There are 24 task cards included in the unit. They are all tasks that include short texts to practice the skills. These work great in whole group lessons, partner work, or for individual student notebook responses.

The tasks are differentiated. The reading level and question prompts get more complex as you move from Task 1 to Task 24.

Reading Response Sheets

There are multiple structured reading response sheets included. There are additional quick prompts that fit on top of a notebook page. I recommend putting these in at the end of your unit and then asking students to return to these prompts throughout the year.

This product will save you so much time when it comes to planning for guided reading, group reading lessons, interventions, and independent student reading.

******************** FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ********************

Are the passages included here the same as the passages in your 2nd grade or 3rd grade close reading bundles?

No, the passages included in this reading notebook are totally new.

What Lexile level are the reading passages?

The Common Core standards consider 2nd and 3rd grade level texts within the same Lexile level band of 450-790. This unit contains twelve original passages written within this level. In addition, the passages have also been rewritten at a lower level and they all fall within a Lexile level of 390-580 which is perfect for your developing learners who are ready for some rich tasks.

Do you have to use this product in a notebook?

No, you do not have to use this in a notebook. There are two options included - notebook style or print-and-go style. YOU choose what YOU need.

- Alyssha Swanson

Teaching and Tapas: 2nd Grade in Spain

Total Pages
80 pages
Answer Key
Teaching Duration
3 Weeks
Report this Resource
Reported resources will be reviewed by our team. Report this resource to let us know if this resource violates TpT’s content guidelines.
Digital Download
Report this resource

Teachers Pay Teachers is an online marketplace where teachers buy and sell original educational materials.

Learn More

Keep in Touch!

Sign Up