This is a series of case studies of supreme court cases regarding challenges on first amendment rights. These studies, each pertaining to a different court ruling, can be distributed to small breakout groups of students to discuss. Each case study describes a real-life scenario where first amendment rights are challenged. The students will discuss what they think should happen based on the information given to them. There is also a set of "answers" that shows the result of the scenario as it happened historically. The teacher can also use this set of case studies in a socratic discussion format instead, with the entire class discussing each study.