I get it. Everyone hates ice breakers. I hated them when I was a student... but you know what? They're necessary!
When I start a new school year, and I'm working on community building, I do small group discussions with a list of silly, high school appropriate, questions. Don't want to come up with questions? Don't want to wade through R-rated stuff on the internet?
Here you go! Throw these questions out and eavesdrop on the conversations and silliness that ensues. Forty questions total, split evenly between "would you rather" and open-ended questions.