Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ

Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Has Impeachment Worked as the Framers Intended? DBQ
Grade Levels
Common Core Standards
Product Rating
File Type

Compressed Zip File

Be sure that you have an application to open this file type before downloading and/or purchasing.

2 MB|35 pages
Product Description
The word “impeachment” is never far from the lips of anyone who is unhappy with a president of the United States, but how did the Framers of the US Constitution intend impeachment to be used, and has our behavior met their expectations? What are the rules that govern its use, and what does it really mean to impeach someone?

This lesson examines impeachment closely. Students will analyze the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, Constitutional Convention records, a selection from the Federalist Papers, the US Constitution, and data tables that show how impeachment proceedings advanced in the legislature since Reconstruction. Special attention is paid to why the phrase “high crimes and misdemeanors” appears in the US Constitution, and examples of what the Framers thought met this threshold are included.

These materials are appropriate for a US I course, and can be used to teach the Constitutional Convention. This packet is also designed to standalone as a dedicated unit on impeachment. The contents provide a framework to understand impeachment as a legal tool, and will serve as a useful background to understand any Article 2 event that may occur in the future.

Similar to my Partition of India Simulation, this lesson took over 250 hours to create. Please feel free to email me at thedesimonestore@gmail.com with any questions.

Lesson Plan – Total Time: 5-7 days
DBQs can be used in many ways, but this lesson supposes teachers will have students read and answer the questions that relate to the DBQ, (2-3 days), then follow one of two tracks:

• Have students write a five-paragraph essay that answers the question “Has impeachment worked as the Framers intended? Support your answer with in-text citations.” (3-4 additional days)

• Discuss the merits of impeachment in a Socratic Seminar/fishbowl. Students will come to class ready to discuss questions provided to them using a completed reference sheet. (3 additional days)

Abstract of DBQ:
As the Framers of the US Constitution assembled in Philadelphia they had many difficult tasks ahead of them. What began as an effort to reform the Articles of Confederation quickly became a total overhaul of the US government. One of the items the delegates sorted through was creating an executive branch along with a new chief magistrate to lead them. With King George III’s tyranny still in their memory, the Framers were careful to build safeguards into the system incase this new leader needed to be removed. But what should the rules for dismissal be, and how did the delegates come to them? If used today, how would we know if removal worked as the Framers intended?

DBQ Resources Included:
• Two pre-reading sheets: a vocab list, and brief summary of delegates appearing in this DBQ
• An introduction essay contextualizing the DBQ (638 words)
• Document 1 - Preambles to Founding Documents (169 words)
• Document 2 - Executive Power and Impeachment References in the US Constitution (442 words)
• Document 3 - Should We Have Impeachment? (482 words)
• Document 4 - Grounds for Impeachment (450 words)
• Document 5 - Clarifying High Crimes and Misdemeanors (470 words)
• Document 6* - Cautions and Problems of Impeachment (538 words)
• Document 7 - Civic Responsibility (57 words)

* Document 6 includes data tables showing impeachment votes by offence, party, and president

Other Resources Included:
• DBQ Question sheet and answer key
• Supporting PowerPoint for instructions
• Essay assignment description and rubric
• Essay outline writing guide
• Socratic Seminar observation checklist

**I made a video describing this lesson. Click here to watch a YouTube tutorial.**

Terms of Use:
This product is to be used by the original downloader only. Copying for more than one teacher, classroom, department, school, or school system is prohibited. Additional licenses may be purchased at a discounted price. This product nor its constituent components may not be resold or used for commercial gain. This product may not be distributed or displayed digitally for public view. Failure to comply is a copyright infringement and a violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). The author of this work is the copyright holder and reserves all rights. Images used are in the public domain.

Check out my other US History lessons!
Vietnam Debate and Simulation
World War II Movie Reaction Paper Assignment
Mayflower Compact - Guided Reading
Infographics On Gun Violence In America
Total Pages
35 pages
Answer Key
Teaching Duration
1 Week
Report this Resource
Digital Download
More products from The DeSimone Store
Product Thumbnail
Product Thumbnail
Product Thumbnail
Product Thumbnail
Product Thumbnail
Digital Download
Teachers Pay Teachers

Teachers Pay Teachers is an online marketplace where teachers buy and sell original educational materials.

Learn More

Keep in Touch!

Sign up