This product contains 5 short documents and a graphic organizer. It asks students to evaluate the extent to which Lincoln deserves the title of Great Emancipator. Students use the T Chart graphic organizer to categorize the documents. I used this in my 11th grade US History class and it created a lot of debate and discussion. If you purchase feel free to contact me and I will send you the lesson plan and ppt that I used free of charge. You can edit it for your classroom needs.