There are so many revising checklists out there--and most of them confuse or intermingle revising with editing. I use this peer-revising checklist with my students as they critique one another's long composition essays. It is detailed, but I feel includes all the essential elements to create an effective essay. Using the checklist takes a little teaching, but once the students are comfortable with it, they then have some guidelines when they look over eachother's writing!
The thumbnails moved a few parts, but when dowloaded, everything is in the right order!