I teach yearbook, lit mag, photojournalism and journalism. I use these to critique photographer's out-of-class assignments for the publications.
Critiques are essential tools to help young photographers get better. I use these sheets to track two things- one, that the student shot the event, and two, that I sat down and looked over their photos with them. My grading breakdown is on the back of the sheet because I want them to be able to see their critique on its own without being tied to a grade. Technical qualities are a combination of correct focus, exposure, composition, and white balancing.