This PDF file includes pilgrim dialogue worksheets. Students partner up and create a short dialogue between two pilgrims. I did include worksheets between 2 pilgrim girls, 2 pilgrim boys, and between 1 boy and 1 girl so you have a worksheet for each partner.
Students can talk about arriving on the Mayflower, food, traditions, their clothing, meeting the Native Americans/Indians, the land, who they miss from home, where they came from, etc. This is not only a writing prompt but it helps students understand the lives of Pilgrims a little bit better. Enjoy!