Reading Response Menus Digital and Printable *EDITABLE*

Rated 4.86 out of 5, based on 6785 reviews
6.8k Ratings
Not So Wimpy Teacher
Grade Levels
3rd - 5th
Formats Included
  • Zip
42 pages
Share this resource
Report this resource to TPT
Not So Wimpy Teacher

What educators are saying

This are a great resource for having your readers connect to what they are reading and the fact that you can edit them is great!
I am using this for homework this year. I love the variety of responses so I can always change things up for my students.


“Great resource to hold students accountable by writing about what they are reading and using evidence from the text. My students enjoy these because they feel like they have a choice and it's not just a prompt for everyone. Thank you!” - Jennifer B.

Every week, a teacher must grapple with an ancient mystery: “I love that my students are reading independently! But, how do I make sure they understand what they’re reading? How do I hold them accountable?”

Wonder no more! These Reading Response Menus will reveal all. Each question in the menu was designed to:

  • Encourage students to use those higher-order thinking skills and dig deep into the text for answers—increasing their comprehension and understanding.
  • Help them practice writing about text and using text evidence—which also prepares them for standardized testing.
  • Allow you to easily assess their comprehension skills—so you can identify areas for improvement.

Best of all? Students really love this activity (see the reviews!) because they can choose from the menu—which lets them pick the questions they feel most confident about answering.

Teachers love them because they can use the printable version in class or they can share these engaging reading menus digitally, as you will find both digital and printable versions are included in this resource.

You can use these menus for independent reading and more! Include them in a writing center, a book/literature club, or a homework assignment. Students can even use these menus during class read-alouds.


Menus provide easy differentiation. Students can choose books on their level. Teachers can limit menu choices to either lower- or higher-order questions based on student needs.

How It Works

Each week, students read their own book. Next, they choose one question from the weekly menu, answer it, and use the self-checklist to edit their work. There’s a simple rubric for you to score the responses based on completion, sentence quality, text evidence, thoughtfulness, and grammar/spelling. Students can record their scores on a data graph and make goals for future responses.

What’s Inside

★ This product includes 36 printable menus (one for every week of the school year!), and each menu contains 9 questions for students to choose from. Six of those questions are geared toward fiction. The other three are geared toward nonfiction and/or information texts.

★ You'll also find a digital version that can be shared with students while distance learning. The menus are colorful and include interactive tracking sheets for students to stay on top of their work.

★ I’ve also included an editable PowerPoint file so you can make additional menus that meet student or class needs! You’ll love how customizable this resource is! 

Also included:

  • Rationale for using menus
  • Suggested uses for menus
  • Teaching tips
  • Differentiation ideas
  • Scoring rubrics
  • Student data graph (for tracking their progress)
  • Writing paper
  • Writing paper (with rubric on the paper)
  • 36 question menus with a self-check at the end

Please check out the preview to get a better idea of what is included and how it can be used in your classroom.


Other ELA resources:

Vocabulary Word Builders FULL YEAR Bundle

Personal Narrative Writing Unit

Reading Exit Tickets

Book Club Fiction and Nonfiction Bundle

Total Pages
42 pages
Answer Key
Teaching Duration
1 Year
Report this resource to TPT
Reported resources will be reviewed by our team. Report this resource to let us know if this resource violates TPT’s content guidelines.


Questions & Answers


TPT empowers educators to teach at their best.

More About Us

Keep in Touch!

Sign Up