Here are some red & white polka dot name tags that will be perfect for your classroom theme!
Included in the sale is a pdf document that prints 2 name tags on one piece of paper. The BEST part--they're EDITABLE! You can type your students' names directly into the document! The font is school text font, which I think is a great model for your students.
Once you've printed your students' name tags on good quality card stock, cut them out, laminate them, and they'll be perfect for the entire school year. (My students' name tags were just as pristine on the last day as they were the first day of school...with a no touching rule, of course!)
Just some additional management info...I have 12" long 2x4 wood pieces that have a slit cut down the center. I painted them to match my classroom theme, and they sit in the middle of the table. My students' name tags sit upright in the slots (2 name tags per name tag holder) and are easily moved when they change seats or when we need the table cleared. It's a little more work in the beginning (making the wood pieces) but they'll last forever and you'll never have to deal with taped-down name tags again. Check out your local hardware store to see if they can cut the 2x4s for you. :)
Thanks for looking!