This is a writing rubric for fiction, and nonfiction writing.
It was purposely made to guide editing, in all genres of writing.
It addresses the CCSS.
I like to make a checklist, with the students, of specific things they should have for that genre/structure.
For example, the area of sentence structure:
I discuss with the students the need to use more figurative language, if it's a personal narrative.
I made the spaces large enough, so the student who is editing the paper can give examples.
Make sure to spend time explaining how to use the rubric. : )