This is the way that I score my students for Socratic Circles. Having so many different skills listed helps students to understand what skills they are lacking so that they can set goals and reflect on their progress. It also helps to have a reason for the grade that they are getting. I have had to refer to this scorecard whenever I get inquiries from parents about the grades students receive for their participation in socratic circles. It helps to have specific skills to refer to at your fingertips.