This product includes both a self and peer evaluation framework for Socratic, fishbowl discussions. This can be used with any text - from articles to short stories to novels.
I recommend printing each evaluation in a different color and assigning partners who then take turns being in the discussion circle and as a coach on the outside of the circle.
I run my seminars as a 7-10 minute discussion, 2 minute coaching break, then back in for 7-10 minutes. Then the partners switch.