I made these (1.5" x 1.5") tags for my classroom, so there may be some that are not useful to you, but I included them anyway just in case! :-) There are 65 different tags!
They are designed 8 tags to fit on a 4" x 6" print (I print at Costco). I then trimmed the bottom inch off, laminated them, cut them into strips of 4, hole-punched them, and finally cut them into individual tags. A great job for parent volunteers in my future! HA!
If you do Accelerated Reader, there are 5- and 10-point tags and then every 10 increments up to 80.
If you have a detective theme, you may be able to use my "ranking" tags (in my classroom economy, students earn a new rank [12 levels "Gumshoe" to "Super Sleuth"] when they earn another $1000.)
I've included tags for the Seven Traits for Success: Curiosity, Gratitude, Grit, Optimism, Self-Control, Social Intelligence, and Zest
Otherwise, there are tags to reward efforts such as Great Handwriting, an Artist, a Buddy, and just plain "Happy"! :-) There are more than 30 tags that any student would love to have!