This PDF file is a T-chart comparing Thanksgiving food then and now. On the one side, write what the Pilgrims and Native Americans/Indians ate and on the other side, what we today as "Americans" eat for Thanksgiving Day.
*Remember, some students will have different answers. Maybe some have ham instead of turkey (I know my grandmother does) but this will show just how diverse we are! Also, the more answers - the better it is to compare the two eras. Enjoy!
**I also have a 60 page Thanksgiving ELA/MATH packet available in my store. It is jam-packed of Thanksgiving stuff and even includes this printable, here.