I did this prompt today and my first graders had a blast! They pretended they were turkeys and I wanted to eat them. They had to give me lots of reasons to convince me not to eat them. After they wrote we shared our writing. On the white board we made two columns one was to write down the kids names that I no longer wanted to eat because they convinced me not too. In the other column we listed the children who did not convince me and I still wanted to eat for Thanksgiving dinner. So much fun!