Also included in
- Grab a bargain - History Mystery lessons for less! (Over 20% off actually!)This bundle contains lessons to help your students deduce, infer and evaluate arguments and evidence. They are suitable for middle and high school and have been a great success in my and others' classrooms. I will be crea$24.00$33.50Save $9.50
Get your students thinking like historians and evaluating evidence.
In this lesson students have to infer and reach a reasoned judgement based on the evidence at hand. This includes primary sources and information to help them decide its reliability.
This lesson can be taught to the whole class from the front but works just as well as stations lesson by simply printing out the slides as whole pages and using them for information gathering.
The class work in pairs to decide whether Richard III killed his nephews, Prince Edward and Prince Richard in the Tower of London. They use the evidence and given information to decide whether he did it, someone else with a mother motive did it or they were sent into exile. There is also opportunity for the class to make up their own theories based on what they discover.
The evidence is not given to them all at once, instead the teacher drip feeds it throughout the lesson. This is in a bid to challenge preconceived ideas and see if pupils will change their minds when faced with new data or sources.
They begin with an outline of the story on the board. Then in 3 minute intervals more evidence is presented either on the whiteboard or on a sheet of clues.
The last task is to write an extended piece (like a DBQ) explaining what they think happened to the boys and why.
The lesson fits with the common core requirement for students to analyse, evaluate and consider causation and consequence. The level descriptors of Emerging, Developing, Securing and Mastering relate to the historical skills needed to identify, describe, explain and then evaluate at the top end of ability.
The zip file contains:
- 16 slide, fully animated powerpoint
- Answer worksheet with a table to complete
- the slides are annotated underneath for the teacher to explain the activity at each point.
My classes have had great fun with this lesson. It can stand alone or be used as part of a project, for example on monarchy or the early Tudors.
I hope you find this useful and enjoyable. If you do, please check out my other History Mysteries, including my Bundle...
THE TOLLUND MAN MURDER MYSTERY.
WHO WAS JACK THE RIPPER?
THE MARY CELESTE HISTORY MYSTERY
TIME TEAM – WHAT CAN WE LEARN FROM ARTIFACTS?
THE GREAT FIRE OF LONDON HISTORY MYSTERY
HISTORY MYSTERIES BUNDLE!
And if you are interested in literacy for history:
PEEL paragraph Placemat
This download (free or purchased) is for your own personal use in your classroom or your home. Please do not share my resources with others unless given explicit consent by me. Please direct them to my store instead. https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Store/Ms-Hughes-Teaches
This download MAY NOT be used in whole or in part on any distance learning course platforms including, but not exclusive to, Outschool or Udemy.
You may not share this download. You may not alter any item in this download, resell and claim as your own work. Similarly, you may not sell or share these resources with anyone and you may not use the contents of this download to create anything for commercial purposes or other commercial products. If you are an education board or school and would like to use my resources district wide, please contact me about licensing.
http://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Store/Ms-Hughes-4067 ©Amy Hughes (MsHughesTeaches) All rights reserved, 2019.
Plantagenet Stuarts Tudors Kings Queens Britain evidence sources history analysis monarchy