The Bill of Rights grant us privileges, but what if your right conflicts with mine? Who wins? This scenario/critical thinking based activity has students defend their position when supporting one party's rights means violating another party's rights. Students have to further analyze the situation from two different perspectives: One from the perspective of a judge ruling on the case; the second, from the perspective of a business owner who has something to lose if things don't go their way. Great for the following courses: Government, Civics, Law, Business Law and Business Management.