I advise the largest chronological yearbook in my state. At 400+ pages, it's very important that we are organized, our pages are completed quickly, and my staff creates excellent spreads. I use this grading rubric the ensure that the spreads my staff submit for publication are nothing short of perfect.
The rubric covers writing, design, alignment, photography, quotes, coverage, tagging, and spelling. Additionally, there is space to not whether or not the spread was completed on time.