TPT
Total:
$0.00
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit
Share

What others say

"My team and I were having trouble finding resources for Compare and Contrast for Non-fiction and this was exactly what we were looking for! Very helpful and extremely easy to follow and use."
star
Christie K.
"This is an amazing resource! I have been using it to help walk my tutoring student through writing different essays and this resource has made it very easy for her. "
star
Marissa G.

Description

This unit has a total of 6 reading passages, teacher and student anchor charts, and 10 days of lesson plans to assist your students in learning all of the necessary skills to write an essay that compares and contrasts two different passages on the same topic. This is a great unit for test prep writing practice.

This unit is intended to be used over a two-week time frame, but this can easily be adjusted to meet your needs.

This unit was written with 3rd and 4th grade in mind. I suggest looking over the preview to determine if it is a good fit for your specific class.

Included in this unit:

  • Detailed teacher directions and suggestions for simple implementation
  • 10 days of lesson plans that include guiding questions, materials, mini lessons, student work tasks, and student share tasks
  • 6 original informational passages (3 pairs of passages on the same topic. These will be used for mini lessons, student tasks, and an extra set is included that can be used for more practice or as an assessment)
  • 12 teacher anchor charts (blank and filled in versions)
  • 9 Student anchor charts and printables
  • Rubrics
  • Publishing paper

Lessons Included:

  • How to mark up the text
  • Compare and contrast using a T-chart
  • Drafting comparison and contrasting paragraphs
  • How to refer to the text
  • Drafting introduction and conclusion paragraphs
  • Editing
  • Publishing

A Typical Day:

Mini Lesson:

The unit includes 10 lesson plans with a suggested mini lesson. The lessons include the use of 2 passages (that are included in the unit) and anchor charts. Teacher versions of the anchor chart are included in the unit so that the teacher can project them and fill them out with the class, or print them and display in the classroom. Small versions are included for the students to fill out and keep in their writing notebooks as a reference and to help draft their essay.

Work Time:

Students will be applying the skill from the mini lesson into their writing each day. The students will have 2 passages (Football and Rugby) that they will use to compare and contrast during this time.

Share Time:

Lesson plans include a specific task for students each day that allows them to share some piece of their writing with a partner or with the class.

How can I use this resource in my classroom?

There are many ways that this resource can be used. Here are some ideas:

  • Whole group reading lesson
  • Reading small group lesson
  • Writing workshop

Please let me know if you have any questions.

*******

More writing units:

Compare and Contrast Fiction

Text Dependent Opinion

Reading Response

Second Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

Third Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

Fourth Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

Fifth Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

*******

Report this resource to TPT
Reported resources will be reviewed by our team. Report this resource to let us know if this resource violates TPT's content guidelines.

Compare and Contrast Nonfiction Reading Response Essay Writing Unit

Not So Wimpy Teacher
102.4k Followers
$6.75

Highlights

Grades icon
Grades
Standards icon
Standards
Pages
50
Answer Key
Rubric only
Teaching Duration
2 Weeks

What others say

"My team and I were having trouble finding resources for Compare and Contrast for Non-fiction and this was exactly what we were looking for! Very helpful and extremely easy to follow and use."
star
Christie K.
"This is an amazing resource! I have been using it to help walk my tutoring student through writing different essays and this resource has made it very easy for her. "
star
Marissa G.

Save even more with bundles

“Great resource for teaching written response for state testing. I love the interactive nature and the natural flow of the ‘I do, We do, you do.’” Delaney D. (Reading Response Essay Writing) “When prepping students for high stakes testing, reading paired texts and responding by writing a constructed
Price $33.00Original Price $40.50Save $7.50
6

Description

This unit has a total of 6 reading passages, teacher and student anchor charts, and 10 days of lesson plans to assist your students in learning all of the necessary skills to write an essay that compares and contrasts two different passages on the same topic. This is a great unit for test prep writing practice.

This unit is intended to be used over a two-week time frame, but this can easily be adjusted to meet your needs.

This unit was written with 3rd and 4th grade in mind. I suggest looking over the preview to determine if it is a good fit for your specific class.

Included in this unit:

  • Detailed teacher directions and suggestions for simple implementation
  • 10 days of lesson plans that include guiding questions, materials, mini lessons, student work tasks, and student share tasks
  • 6 original informational passages (3 pairs of passages on the same topic. These will be used for mini lessons, student tasks, and an extra set is included that can be used for more practice or as an assessment)
  • 12 teacher anchor charts (blank and filled in versions)
  • 9 Student anchor charts and printables
  • Rubrics
  • Publishing paper

Lessons Included:

  • How to mark up the text
  • Compare and contrast using a T-chart
  • Drafting comparison and contrasting paragraphs
  • How to refer to the text
  • Drafting introduction and conclusion paragraphs
  • Editing
  • Publishing

A Typical Day:

Mini Lesson:

The unit includes 10 lesson plans with a suggested mini lesson. The lessons include the use of 2 passages (that are included in the unit) and anchor charts. Teacher versions of the anchor chart are included in the unit so that the teacher can project them and fill them out with the class, or print them and display in the classroom. Small versions are included for the students to fill out and keep in their writing notebooks as a reference and to help draft their essay.

Work Time:

Students will be applying the skill from the mini lesson into their writing each day. The students will have 2 passages (Football and Rugby) that they will use to compare and contrast during this time.

Share Time:

Lesson plans include a specific task for students each day that allows them to share some piece of their writing with a partner or with the class.

How can I use this resource in my classroom?

There are many ways that this resource can be used. Here are some ideas:

  • Whole group reading lesson
  • Reading small group lesson
  • Writing workshop

Please let me know if you have any questions.

*******

More writing units:

Compare and Contrast Fiction

Text Dependent Opinion

Reading Response

Second Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

Third Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

Fourth Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

Fifth Grade (Narrative, Opinion & Informational)

*******

Report this resource to TPT
Reported resources will be reviewed by our team. Report this resource to let us know if this resource violates TPT's content guidelines.

Reviews

4.8
Rated 4.85 out of 5, based on 284 reviews
284
ratings
5
242
4
40
3
2
2
0
1
0
Mostly used with 3rd grade
Reviews
1
1
4
156
86
21
6
K
1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th
All verified TPT purchases
Very Useful Resource
Rated 5 out of 5
July 18, 2026
Met expectations
Great value
Standards-aligned
My team and I were having trouble finding resources for Compare and Contrast for Non-fiction and this was exactly what we were looking for! Very helpful and extremely easy to follow and use.
Christie K.
172 reviews • California
Grades taught: 3rd
Student populations: Autism, Learning difficulties
A Strong Resource
Rated 5 out of 5
May 18, 2026
Met expectations
Great value
Standards-aligned
This is an amazing resource! I have been using it to help walk my tutoring student through writing different essays and this resource has made it very easy for her.
Marissa G.
277 reviews • Outside the United States
Grades taught: 6th
Not So Wimpy Teacher
Response from
Not So Wimpy Teacher
(TPT Seller)
Jun 4, 2026

Thank you for your feedback. I'm glad the resource was helpful.

Step by Step Writing Process
Rated 5 out of 5
April 1, 2026
This resource does such an amazing job walking the teacher and students through steps of mastery.
Laura P.
315 reviews • California
Grades taught: 3rd
Wonderful Resource!
Rated 5 out of 5
March 23, 2026
I used this to prepare for SBAC testing. Very Helpful!
Lucky Teacher
(TPT Seller)
373 reviews • California
Grades taught: 3rd
Not So Wimpy Teacher
Response from
Not So Wimpy Teacher
(TPT Seller)
Mar 23, 2026

Thank you for your feedback. I'm glad the resource was helpful.

A great resource!
Rated 5 out of 5
March 16, 2026
Met expectations
Great value
Standards-aligned
This was a great way to support my students while learning compare and contrast writing!
210 reviews • Ohio
Grades taught: 3rd
Not So Wimpy Teacher
Response from
Not So Wimpy Teacher
(TPT Seller)
Mar 17, 2026

Thank you for your feedback. I'm glad the resource was helpful.

A Great Nonfiction Resource
Rated 5 out of 5
February 6, 2026
Met expectations
Great value
Standards-aligned
A great Nonfiction Resource! A Great essay writing unit!
Tracy G.
1,141 reviews • Kentucky
Grades taught: 4th
Not So Wimpy Teacher
Response from
Not So Wimpy Teacher
(TPT Seller)
Feb 10, 2026

I'm glad you are happy with the resource. Thank you for your feedback.

Complete Unit Ready to Go
Rated 5 out of 5
December 15, 2025
Met expectations
Great value
Standards-aligned
I used this for a tutoring student. It was a complete unit ready to go!
The Learning Ladder
(TPT Seller)
973 reviews • Georgia
Grades taught: 3rd
Not So Wimpy Teacher
Response from
Not So Wimpy Teacher
(TPT Seller)
Dec 16, 2025

Thank you for your feedback. I'm glad the resource was helpful.

Great Resource
Rated 5 out of 5
September 27, 2025
This was an awesome resource, so glad to have used it in my classroom. Thanks
meredith W.
114 reviews
Grades taught: 3rd

Questions & Answers

Loading

Standards

to see state-specific standards (only available in the US).
Compare and contrast the most important points and key details presented in two texts on the same topic.
Write informative/explanatory texts to examine a topic and convey ideas and information clearly.
Loading